About Bay Street Pharmacy

Bay Street Pharmacy is a second generation pharmacist-owned family pharmacy established in 1984. We service the great Northern Indian River and south Brevard area. Bay Street Pharmacy’s motto is “Where caring people care for you” and our exceptional team accomplishes that by providing individual care to each patient. We also always have 2 pharmacists on duty to answer your questions and counsel you on your prescription and non-prescription items.

Owner and pharmacist, Theresa Tolle, along with pharmacists, Cheryl Grage, Lynn Littleton, Maurice Wilson, and Tina Finnegan, and our other dedicated staff are committed to fulfilling our customers’ needs. When it comes to your health or the health of your loved ones, please feel confident that we will handle your concerns with care and compassion. Please let us know how we can serve you.

Meet the Pharmacists

Theresa Tolle is owner and chief pharmacist of Bay Street Pharmacy, along with her husband Joe since 1999. Theresa is knowledgeable in many aspects of the healthcare industry. Theresa is proud to be owner of a pharmacy “where caring people care for you” and invites you to come in and see for yourself. She loves being pharmacist and owner of Bay Street Pharmacy because we are able to be purposeful and spend time with our patients, getting to know them and improving their health. Together with her husband Joe, they are thankful that God blessed them with the opportunity to serve their community.

Lynn Littleton joined us in August of 2005. Prior to joining our team, she worked in the Sebastian area for many years and managed Medicine Shoppe in Roseland. Her favorite part of being a Bay Street Pharmacy pharmacist is being able to help with difficult or out of the ordinary circumstances that may come up with healthcare. Also, she enjoys compounding individualized prescriptions for patients that may not be available by other means. In her free time, she likes to hang out with her 5 children and 5 grandchildren or host bible studies at her home with local teenagers.

Maurice Wilson joined the Bay Street team in 2018. Prior to joining our team, he was pharmacy manager at Walmart for 25 years. Maurice loves the extra time he gets for patient interaction while working at Bay Street. In his free time, he enjoys looking through his model cars, disassembling and assembling watches, and staying active outside!

Cheryl Grage graduated from Long Island University in 1995. Prior to moving to Florida, she was a Supervising Pharmacist for Pathmark Supermarket Pharmacy. She joined our Bay Street Pharmacy team in 2006. Her favorite part of being a Bay Street Pharmacy pharmacist is getting to establish a relationship with our loyal patients. In her free time, she likes to watch Hallmark movies have family dinner with her husband and 2 kids.

Tina Finnegan graduated from Palm Beach Atlantic University in 2021 then went on to complete a year-long residency through the University of Florida. She has been a part of the Bay Street Pharmacy team since her senior year of high school. Her favorite part of being a Bay Street Pharmacy pharmacist is having the opportunity to expand services offered to the community and getting to know the patients. In her free time, she likes to relax with her husband and two dogs.